Night Copyright © By Rachel 2001
rights reserved - duplication/copying prohibited
the evening she had had she was practically asleep by the time her head hit the
pillow. For a while now she had been dating both James and Josh, while neither
of her relationships had been "exclusive" she decided to invite the
guys over and tell them she had been seeing both of them before they figured it
out themselves. She explained to them how she had been dating James for a few
months before she met Josh at a party where they just hit it off and started
seeing each other. She told them both how much they meant to her and how she
didn't think it was fair for each of them not to know about the other, and that
she didn't want them to hate her for seeing both of them. Nonetheless they were
both pretty upset, partly because they didn't know she was seeing someone else,
but mostly because of who the other person was. She tried again to explain that
hooking up with the two of them was unintentional that it just kind of happened,
but James, who looked like someone who just had his puppy run over gave her the
silent treatment. Josh on the other hand, was very vocal calling her every name
in the book. Josh stormed out of her place followed by James. Bursting into
tears she ran after them calling their names, but it did no good, they got in
their cars and sped off. She went back inside and directly to the kitchen where
she poured herself a drink, that she quickly finished, then went to bed.
Suddenly she was woken up by the pressure of someone's body on top of hers and
warm breath on her neck, her eyes shot open but the room was pitch black and she
couldn't see a thing. Suddenly his tongue was inside her mouth, exploring every
inch of it. She knew that kiss; it could only be one person. "Josh, what
are you doing here?"
"I came to my senses," he said between kisses, "and decided I
couldn't give you up. Now don't move." With a final kiss he stood up and
she heard him cross the room to the door but then walk right back to her. She
felt his lips on hers once again but something felt different, softer, more
sensual. "Oh my god! James! What are you doing?"
"Well baby," he said running his hand up and down her body,
"neither one of us was willing to let the other one have you so we decided
that the only thing to do was to share you. Now lie back like a good girl."
With that he started kissing her neck, down her breasts, still covered by her
t-shirt, over her exposed stomach to her panties, where he teased her by running
his tongue over the fabric. He tucked his fingers under the elastic crossing
over her hips and pulled her panties off. He kissed and licked his way back up
her legs paying special attention to her inner thigh. He could feel her start to
grind her hips in anticipation of when his wonderful tongue would find her hot
center. At the same time a second pair of hands grasped the bottom of her
t-shirt and pulled it off. Josh immediately took her breast in his mouth and
sucked and bit her taut nipple while James's tongue went to work on her hot, wet
center. Waves of pleasure started to crash over her body. Karen's hands reached
out and found the waistband of Josh's pants and quickly unbuttoned them and
started to push them, as well as his boxers, down. Josh kicked off his pants and
wrapped his legs around Karen's head; she immediately took his rod into her
mouth and began vigorously sucking and licking. The harder James sucked her
swollen clit the harder Karen sucked Josh. Josh continued to squeeze and massage
Karen's tits while James slipped two fingers into Karen's wetness and worked her
from inside. It wasn't long until she felt her orgasm begin, as her hips started
bucking James sucked furiously on her swollen clit and pumped his fingers to
prolong her ecstasy as long as possible. Josh could feel her passion as she
clamped down on his organ working him hard and fast, which quickly brought him
to his end. He spilled his cum into her mouth before collapsing on the bed next
Knowing that James hadn't had the opportunity to feel as good as she and Josh,
Karen quickly undressed him, exposing his beautiful rock hard cock, and sat him
on the edge of the bed, she knelt down in front of him and took his throbbing
hard on into her warm mouth. His eyes rolled back and he grabbed the back of her
head as she expertly licked and sucked his manhood. She started at the base of
his cock and licked all the way up to the tip, he groaned with pleasure, begging
her not to stop. Again she licked up and down, up and down, from base to tip.
James took a hold of Karen's breasts and started rubbing and kneading them, his
moans continued as Karen chimed in with her own. Turned on by this, Josh knelt
behind her and slammed his member into her wet pussy. James continued to massage
her breasts and pinched her nipples as Josh reached around and fingered her clit
while he fucked her hard. Karen squeezed James's balls as she rose and fell on
his twitching prick. James came hard, spilling his hot sex into her mouth; she
swallowed down every last drop then continued to gently lick and tease his tip
causing him to cum again. This excited Karen on so much she immediately released
her juices all over Josh's throbbing dick and with one final thrust he shot his
load deep within her.
The trio rested on the bed trying to return their breathing to normal, James was
running his fingers through Karen's hair as Josh drew small circles around her
belly button. She ran her hand up and down Josh's muscular arm as he drew on her
stomach, she turned and kissed James softly but passionately, the tension grew
as she and James turned their bodies to face each other and she wrapped her leg
around him. She felt him enter her; he was grinding slowly in and out of her
warm pussy, causing deep moans of pleasure to escape her throat. She felt Josh's
hands cup her breasts as he entered her slowly from behind. It was like nothing
she had ever felt before. The heat and friction between them grew. When she
kissed James, Josh would run his tongue across her smooth shoulders, then as she
turned her head so Josh's tongue could probe her mouth James would lick and suck
up and down her neck. Fucking, sucking, rubbing, grabbing, grinding. The three
found a rhythm as they rocked together, back and forth, and in and out.
The intensity was getting to be too much for them, as their breathing was
getting heavier and more irregular, "Oh god, I'm going to cum!" Josh
shouted. He mercilessly slammed into Karen's tightness harder and harder causing
her to grind James even harder. The three came together in a sea of moans and
screams of ecstasy. Exhausted, they collapsed on their backs and quickly drifted
off to sleep.
She had no idea how long they had all been asleep, but she decided that a warm
bath was in order. She got up slowly so as not to wake the guys, and went into
the bathroom, ran a bubble bath and lit some candles. It felt good as she eased
down into the warm soapy water. She leaned her head back, closed her eyes, and
replayed the evening's events in her mind. She had never thought anything like
that would ever happen to her, especially with those two.
But as good as the evening was she knew she only wanted to be with on of them.
The one she'd always wanted. The bathroom door creaked open slowly; she looked
over to see him standing there. He looked beautiful through the mist and
candlelight. Although he was just wearing a white t-shirt and some old ripped
jeans he looked better than she had ever seen him look.
"Hi, can I come in?" She waved him. He walked over to the edge of the
tub, sat down, leaned in, and gave Karen a soft kiss on the forehead, "Are
you okay baby?"
"Yeah, I'm a little sore after the way you two tossed me around tonight,
but I'm okay." She gave him a weak smile. He could see in her eyes she was
holding something back.
"Karen, I want you to know that tonight was his idea." He said
pointing toward the bedroom, "The only reason I went along with it is
because I figured you would choose him over me. He wasn't going to back down and
I couldn't stand the idea of you two together so I figured sharing you was
better than losing you. But it's not. Karen, I want to be with you and only you
and I want you to be with me and only me."
"I want that too." She said trying to hold back her tears,
"You're the one I truly care about. I know that now. He's a great guy and
all but you and I have a something more, we have a connection, and I'm really
falling hard for you."
He gently kissed her lips letting her know he felt the same way. She got out of
the tub and he wrapped her robe around her body and kissed her again. It was a
long, slow, strong, passionate kiss that made Karen weak in the knees. "I
guess we should go tell him," she said pulling out of the kiss.
They walked into the bedroom but found it empty. There was a note sitting on the
I overheard what you two said and I can see that you really care about each
other. I can't say that I'm not disappointed, but you are two of my best friends
and I'm happy you have found each other. Love, Josh
"Well I guess that takes care of that", James said puling her into
another kiss. She could feel his hardening length against her thigh. She pulled
his t-shirt over his head as he untied her robe, pushed it off her shoulders and
dropped it to the floor. He kissed her neck as he laid her down on the bed. He
took off his jeans and slowly pressed his body into hers. He slid into her wet
center slowly so that she could feel every inch of his thick shaft. She began
rocking her hips urging him deeper within her walls. He gladly obliged, he
continued to pulse into her as his tongue teased her nipples, then licked and
kissed his way to her lips, where their tongues intertwined in passion. He
started pumping into her harder as she wailed with pleasure.
"Baby that feels so good, you're going to make me cum. I want to feel you
cum inside me." He followed her demand and a few long forceful strokes
later they exploded as if they were one. Each one spurring on the other's
orgasm. Neither of them had ever felt such intense pleasure before.
James kissed her eyelids, the tip of her nose, and then her mouth before he
rolled off her keeping his arms around her. As he held Karen he whispered softly
into her ear, "Thank you".
"For choosing me."
She kissed him and looked deep into his eyes, "There was never another
choice for me. You're the only person I ever want to be with."
They fell asleep in each other's arms and woke up the next morning still locked
in their embrace and knew it would always be that way.